How we research Journal stories
The Journal tells the stories behind advertisements in the archive. These are the rules we follow when we write them.
The advertisements come first
Every story starts from advertisements in the archive, scanned from the original printed magazines and newspapers. When a story quotes an ad, the words come from the scan, and the ad is shown or linked so you can read it yourself. Each ad page gives its publication, date and catalog number.
Everything else is cited
Facts that do not come from the ads themselves are marked with a numbered note that leads to a list of sources at the end of the story. We look first for primary sources: newspapers and magazines of the time (many through state digitized-newspaper collections), court decisions, government reports, patents and trade catalogs. We also rely on museum and library catalogs and on published scholarship. We use general references such as Wikipedia only for well-established background, and we name them when we do.
When sources disagree, we say so rather than pick one silently. When we cannot confirm a detail, we leave it out or say plainly that it is uncertain.
Claims in the ads are the advertisers’ claims
Many of these advertisements made promises that were false, and some sold products that were dangerous. We quote those promises so readers can see how they were made, and we identify them as the advertiser’s claims. Nothing in the Journal is medical advice.
Prices and wages
To give old prices some meaning, we compare them with what people earned at the time. Unless a story says otherwise, we use the National Bureau of Economic Research’s figures for average hourly earnings in manufacturing and the typical workweek of the period (about 60 hours in the 1890s), and we show the arithmetic. These are averages: many readers earned more, and many earned less.
Pictures from outside the archive
Some stories include photographs or illustrations that are not from our own collection. We use them only when they are in the public domain or have been released under a CC0 dedication, and we check the rights for each individual image at the institution or site that holds it. A photograph of a three-dimensional object, such as a music box or a bicycle, needs its own release from the photographer, even when the object is old. Every outside image is credited in its caption with its creator, date where known, source and rights status. If we cannot establish that an image is public domain or CC0, we do not use it.
How we use AI
We use AI tools to help transcribe the text of advertisements, find and read sources, and draft and edit Journal stories. They make the archive possible to build at its scale, but they can also make mistakes. Every story is reviewed before it is published, the facts in it are checked against the sources listed at the end, and the citations are there so you can check them too. Transcriptions are compared with the scans; if you spot a difference, the scan is the authority, and we would like to hear about it.
Corrections
If you find an error, or know more about an advertisement, its maker or its publication, please email [email protected]. When a correction changes what a story says, we say so in the story.
